Roux Afrique expert conducting a technical survey of industrial equipment for valuation purposes

ROUX AFRIQUE EVS · AFRICA & THE MIDDLE EAST

INSURABLE ASSET VALUATION

PROTECT · VALUE · SECURE

The technical foundation that safeguards your insurance programme and strengthens the credibility of your decisions.

As at a defined valuation date and in a specified currency, Roux Afrique EVS determines and structures the insurable values of buildings, civil works, installations, machinery, equipment and technical assets.

The assignment transforms physical, technical and economic data into a documented, traceable and updateable Statement of Values, ready for use by the company and its brokers, insurers and reinsurers.

SUBSTANTIATING THE INSURED BASIS

An insured value should never be a simple restatement of accounting records

Historical acquisition cost, net book value or the mechanical application of an index does not necessarily represent the current cost of rebuilding or replacing an asset.

Inflation, exchange rates, international freight, non-recoverable duties and taxes, installation costs, engineering, testing, commissioning, access constraints and technological developments can materially alter the capital required to reinstate a site.

  • Substantiate declared asset values
  • Identify variances between existing declared values and estimated values
  • Reduce exposure to underinsurance or unsupported overvaluation
  • Inform underwriting and renewal discussions
  • Facilitate the substantiation of assets and values in the event of a loss
  • Establish a sustainable updating process

The valuation provides a technical basis for decision-making. It does not guarantee the amount of any indemnity or a reduction in premium, both of which remain subject to the definitions, clauses and conditions of the insurance contract.

Stakeholders
CEOsCFOsTechnical DirectorsRisk ManagersInsurance ManagersAsset ManagersBrokersInsurersReinsurers

VALUATION DISCIPLINE

Every value must answer five questions

  1. 01

    WHICH ASSET?

    An identifiable description, location and insurance category.

  2. 02

    WHICH BASIS OF VALUE?

    Reinstatement Value New, Depreciated Value, Fair Market Value or Value in Use.

  3. 03

    AS AT WHAT DATE?

    Every value must be linked to a defined valuation date.

  4. 04

    IN WHICH CURRENCY?

    The currency, exchange rates and their effective date are explicitly stated.

  5. 05

    BASED ON WHICH SOURCES AND ASSUMPTIONS?

    Each result is linked to documented data, calculation parameters and limitations.

BASES OF VALUE

Four clearly differentiated bases of value

01

Reinstatement Value New

For buildings and civil works, this is the estimated cost of rebuilding them as new as at the valuation date.

For machinery, equipment and technical installations, it is the cost of replacement with a modern asset providing equivalent utility, capacity and functional performance.

Depending on the contractual scope, it may include design studies, transport, freight, non-recoverable duties, installation, foundations, erection, testing and commissioning.

02

Depreciated Value

Insurance Value

This is the Reinstatement Value New less documented depreciation, taking into account factors such as age, condition, maintenance and remaining useful life.

Adjustments for functional, technical or economic obsolescence are applied only where justified by the basis of value adopted and the instructions governing the assignment.

The insurance value actually declared may be stated on either a Reinstatement Value New or a Depreciated Value basis. The applicable basis remains determined by the definitions and conditions of the policy.

03

Fair Market Value

Fair Market Value estimates the price at which an asset could be exchanged, as at the valuation date, between knowledgeable, independent parties acting without compulsion, in accordance with the definition expressly adopted in the engagement.

It is an asset-valuation or transactional basis of value. It is not a substitute for the reinstatement value used for Property Damage insurance.

04

Value in Use

Value in Use · Usage Value

Value in Use reflects the asset's entity-specific economic value in its current use, based on assumptions specific to the business and the economic benefits expected from the asset.

It is distinct from market value, financial Fair Value and insurance value.

Methodological rule

These four bases are never combined. The purpose, definition, valuation date, currency and specific assumptions applicable to each are formally established.

SCOPE

A scope aligned with the actual asset base

Depending on the instructions governing the assignment, the valuation may cover:

  • Industrial, commercial and technical buildings
  • Civil engineering structures and property improvements
  • Roads, utilities networks and external infrastructure
  • Electrical systems, fluid systems, HVAC and utilities
  • Machinery, production lines and process equipment
  • Materials-handling, laboratory and control equipment
  • IT, telecommunications and security installations
  • Furniture, fixtures, fittings and general equipment
  • Recent capital expenditure and capital work in progress
  • Assets temporarily idle, retired or scheduled for removal from the scope

Land, inventories, merchandise, intangible assets, vehicles, works of art, third-party property and other specific asset classes are included only where a specific scope and basis of value have been expressly defined.

An asset-allocation matrix distinguishes buildings, general installations, plant and equipment in order to prevent omissions and double counting.

STATEMENT OF VALUES

A usable Statement of Values is more than a total

The Statement of Values — SOV structures insurable values by:

  • Legal entity
  • Establishment and site
  • Building, area or installation
  • Insurance category
  • Asset family
  • Valuation date and currency
  • Value currently declared
  • Reinstatement Value New
  • Depreciated Value
  • Source, assumption and level of documentation

For a multi-site portfolio, values are produced individually for each location and then consolidated using a consistent classification structure.

The principal SOV presents the Reinstatement Value New and the Depreciated Value — Insurance Value. Fair Market Value and Value in Use are presented in separate schedules where included in the engagement.

METHODOLOGY

A methodology combining site work, valuation and control

  1. 01

    DEFINE

    Define the purpose, entities, sites, valuation date, currency, bases of value, asset categories, landlord and tenant responsibilities, and all inclusions and exclusions.

  2. 02

    COLLECT & QUALIFY

    Review the policies, existing SOVs, fixed-asset registers, drawings, invoices, contracts, technical records, equipment lists, capital expenditure and other available sources.

    Accounting data supports reconciliation; it does not automatically replace insurance value.

  3. 03

    CONDUCT THE SITE SURVEY

    Identify and characterise the assets: location, dimensions, construction, function, manufacturer, model, capacity, age, condition, maintenance and installation environment.

    The depth of survey work — exhaustive, targeted or sample-based — is defined in the engagement. A comprehensive physical inventory and the creation of an Asset Register remain a separate assignment.

  4. 04

    CLASSIFY & RECONCILE

    Organise assets by entity, site, area and insurance category. Identify missing assets, duplicates, transfers, recent investments, disposals and allocation inconsistencies.

  5. 05

    MODEL COSTS

    Assess local and imported costs, modern equivalent solutions, freight, non-recoverable duties, installation, engineering, testing and commissioning, within the agreed scope.

    Exchange-rate effects, location, site accessibility and market conditions are addressed separately and linked to the valuation date.

  6. 06

    DETERMINE ADJUSTMENTS

    Determine Depreciated Value on the basis of documented assumptions applied either asset by asset or to homogeneous asset groups where that approach is justified.

    Fair Market Value and Value in Use are determined in accordance with their respective methodologies and assumptions where included in the engagement.

  7. 07

    REVIEW & CONSOLIDATE

    Perform reconciliations, consistency checks, variance analyses, unit-cost checks, double-counting reviews and validation of aggregations.

    Material assumptions, missing data and limitations are subject to expert review before issue.

  8. 08

    DELIVER & UPDATE

    Issue a draft version, collect documented comments, resolve variances and then produce the final report and SOV.

    An updating protocol sets out responsibilities, trigger events, index sources and updating rules.

QA/QC

Quality control centred on traceability

The QA/QC process covers, in particular:

  • Consistency between observed assets and available data
  • Reconciliation with the fixed-asset register and existing SOV
  • Detection of omissions and double counting
  • Verification of quantities, unit costs and aggregations
  • Substantiation of depreciation and adjustments
  • Traceability of sources, currencies, rates and dates
  • Review of material assumptions and limitations
  • Final validation by the responsible experts
Methodological signature

Every value must be linked to an asset, a basis of value, a date, a currency, a source and an assumption.

INVENTYS® · VRA3D

Inventys® and VRA3D supporting data continuity

Technology strengthens the structure, traceability and technical record of the assignment.

01

Inventys®

Inventys® structures the physical, technical, economic and insurance data used throughout the assignment.

  • Multi-site consolidation
  • Organisation of the Statement of Values
  • Traceability of sources and assumptions
  • Variance tracking
  • Version control
  • Future updating cycles
02

VRA3D

Where appropriate, VRA3D supplements the surveys with visual and spatial documentation of buildings, installations and equipment.

  • Asset contextualisation
  • Remote review
  • Preservation of a structured technical record

Technology enhances expertise; it does not replace professional judgement, controls or final validation.

DELIVERABLES

Deliverables designed for insurance and decision-making

Depending on the engagement:

  • 01Valuation report and executive summary
  • 02Detailed schedule of values by site and asset category
  • 03Statement of Values showing Reinstatement Value New and Depreciated Value
  • 04Structured and auditable Excel database
  • 05Reconciliation against declared and accounting values
  • 06Documented variance analysis
  • 07Memorandum of assumptions, sources, sensitivities and limitations
  • 08Fair Market Value and Value in Use schedules, where included
  • 09Photographic record and VRA3D documentation, where relevant
  • 10Updating protocol
  • 11Validated draft and final versions

DECISIVE MOMENTS

When should a valuation be commissioned?

  • Before renewal or restructuring of the Property Damage insurance programme
  • Following an acquisition, extension or major industrial investment
  • Where the SOV is outdated, incomplete or insufficiently detailed
  • Following significant disposals, transfers, replacements or retirements
  • Where inflation, exchange rates, freight or import costs have changed materially
  • To consolidate a multi-site or multinational portfolio
  • In connection with financing, an acquisition or an M&A transaction requiring an additional asset-valuation basis

Updating should not be based solely on a fixed timetable. It should also be triggered by any material change in assets, costs, currencies or the insured perimeter.

CRITICAL ENVIRONMENTS

Environments where value directly affects the balance sheet

Sectors served:

Energy & UtilitiesOil, Gas & PetrochemicalsMining, Metals & MaterialsIndustry & ManufacturingInfrastructureTransport, Ports & LogisticsTelecommunications & Digital InfrastructureAgro-industryReal Estate, Hospitality & Major Property PortfoliosInvestors & Financial Institutions

Our experts operate across Africa, the Maghreb and the Middle East, adapting cost data and models to the technical, logistical and monetary realities of each location.

CLEAR RESPONSIBILITIES

One accountable mandate. Distinct areas of expertise.

01

Insurable Asset Valuation

Determines the values of tangible property required for the SOV.

03

Physical Inventory & Asset Register

Comprehensively identifies assets and organises their physical, technical and accounting reconciliation.

04

Engineering Risk Survey

Analyses hazards, protection measures, vulnerabilities and EML, PML or MFL scenarios.

05

Roux Afrique Advisory

Reviews programme architecture, Risk Financing and insurance Due Diligence matters.

06

Roux Afrique Claims

Establishes and quantifies post-loss damage and structures the claim.

SMP, SME, EML, PML or MFL scenarios and contractual limits of indemnity are not bases of value. They fall within the remit of the Risk Survey or insurance programme structuring.

STANDARDS

Standards and references applied according to the purpose of the engagement

The engagement letter specifies the contractual definitions, bases of value, methodologies, professional standards and applicable local requirements.

  1. 01IVS principles may frame the scope of work, bases of value, data, approaches and documentation
  2. 02Reinstatement Cost Assessment principles may be applied to buildings where their scope is relevant
  3. 03Applicable financial reporting standards are addressed separately for Fair Value and Value in Use
  4. 04Policy definitions and local law remain decisive in determining the value to be declared and the basis of indemnification

A generic reference to a standard is never a substitute for analysing the contract, the scope and the valuation's actual purpose.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

Understanding insurable asset valuation

Why are accounting values insufficient?

Accounting values are governed by recognition, depreciation and financial-reporting rules. They do not necessarily reflect the current cost of rebuilding or replacing assets.

What is the difference between Reinstatement Value New and Depreciated Value?

Reinstatement Value New estimates the current cost of reconstruction or replacement. Depreciated Value applies a documented adjustment that takes account, in particular, of age, condition, maintenance and remaining useful life.

Is Depreciated Value always the insurance value?

No. Depending on the policy, the insured basis may be Reinstatement Value New or Depreciated Value. The contract determines the basis to be declared and the method of indemnification.

What is the difference between insurance value, Fair Market Value and Value in Use?

Insurance value addresses the reconstruction or replacement requirement defined by the policy. Fair Market Value relates to a market transaction. Value in Use reflects the entity-specific economic utility of the asset.

What does the Statement of Values contain?

It presents assets and their values by entity, site, area and category, together with the date, currency, bases of value, sources, assumptions and levels of consolidation adopted.

Does the assignment automatically include a comprehensive inventory?

No. The survey work required for the valuation is defined in the engagement letter. The creation of a comprehensive Asset Register falls within the separate ‘Physical Inventory & Asset Register’ assignment.

How often should values be updated?

Values should be reviewed at renewal and following any material change: acquisition, disposal, extension, replacement or a significant movement in costs, inflation or exchange rates.

Does the valuation guarantee indemnification in the event of a loss?

No. Indemnification depends on the policy, cover, exclusions, deductibles, limits, circumstances of the loss and supporting evidence provided. The valuation supplies a documented basis for substantiating declared asset values.

SUBSTANTIATE VALUE

Do not let a historical value determine your level of protection

Share your sites, current SOV, principal asset categories and the decision you need to make. Roux Afrique EVS will structure the scope, bases of value, methodology and deliverables accordingly.

Speak with Roux Afrique EVS